Showing posts with label Herman Cain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Herman Cain. Show all posts

Thursday, June 14, 2012

The Tea Party's Identity Crisis


I originally published this article at RevoluTimes on December 1, 2011

The political circus being played by the GOP must leave one wondering if the Tea Party has all but abandoned its goals of fiscal restraint and smaller government. Rick Perry, Herman Cain and now Newt Gingrich have all been declared the frontrunner at some point throughout the presidential race despite their support for Big Government programs and government spending. Mitt Romney continues to poll well throughout the country but many conservative activists have refused to warm up to the former Massachusetts governor due to his many inconsistencies on the campaign trail.
This strong trend of searching for the Anti-Romney (similar sentiments were held during his presidential bid in 2008 as well) is rather puzzling considering the embrace given to the aforementioned candidates by much of the Republican Party and Tea Party supporters. The Tea Party and conservative activists across the country pride themselves on being defenders of capitalism, lower taxes and cuts to federal spending; but their propensity to latch onto whomever the Republican Party and conservative media is promoting at the moment makes this claim questionable at best.
The schizophrenia of right wing voters began with Rick Perry. As I’ve documented elsewhere, the Texas governor has a laundry list of tax hikes, corporate welfare and even a government mandate for young girls to purchase and be submitted to an HPV vaccine. As if this wasn’t enough to eradicate any rumors of Perry’s fiscal conservatism, Perry staunchly supported the springboard for the Tea Party movement: TARP. Indeed, not only did Perry support the bailout, he co-authored a letter with then president of the Democratic Governors Association, Joe Manchin saying,
“…There is a time for partisanship and there is a time for getting things done…and now is not the time to assign blame. It is time for D.C. to step up and be responsible and do what’s in the best interest of American taxpayers and our economy…It’s time for leadership. Congress needs to act now.”
Perry’s well-known history of pandering to special interests and unimpressive debate performances led many within the Tea Party to look towards Atlanta businessman Herman Cain. Cain’s candidacy had been an afterthought for several weeks due to his lack of name recognition; but his apparent outsider demeanor made him far more attractive as voters looked for an anti-establishment candidate. Yet again the so-called conservative media and grassroots organizers touted the latest frontrunner as a stalwart defender of free markets and fiscal responsibility. Little did most Republicans know, (and most still don’t know), Cain oncecondemned a national sales tax only to propose his own, vehemently opposes the notion of ending the Fed and restoring sound money and the coup de grâce of course was Cain’s op-ed in strong support of TARP saying,
“…Wake up people! Owning a part of the major banks in America is not a bad thing. We could make a profit while solving a problem. But the mainstream media and thefree market purists want you to believe that this is the end of capitalism as we know it. It is not for several reasons that they have conveniently not explained…” (emphasis added)
It seems Mr. Cain believed the stealing of your wealth was just a wise investment the State was obliged to make for you. But despite his tarnished record and brand of political whimsy, the former CEO of Godfather’s Pizza held strong until allegations regarding his personal life were made public recently.
At this point the conservative masses were more than happy to offer the musical chair to former House Speaker Newt Gingrich. It’s not surprising to see the Georgia native rising in the polls as he’s very well known for his debate skills. It is baffling however that anyone with a straight face could claim Newt Gingrich believes in the free market or fiscal responsibility in any form. Not only did Gingrich support TARP, he staunchly supported the creation of the unconstitutional Department of Education, (and continues to push for its expansion) NAFTA and GATT, various federal subsidies, flip-flopped on Climate Change, received nearly $2 million from Freddie Mac and has repeatedly expressed his support for a federal mandate to purchase health insurance in some manner. And just to illustrate how little concern he has for actually cutting spending, Gingrich referred to the rather modest cuts presented earlier this year by Congressman Paul Ryan as “right wing social engineering”, only to once again change his mind later.
If the Tea Party and its supporters truly wish to be an agent of change and usher in a new age of free markets, sound money and fiscal restraint, they have a very strange way of showing it. As of right now, their choices in a presidential candidate will only result in them becoming a silenced wing of the Republican Party with little influence, and even less credibility. I’d suggest they return to their roots.

Herman Cain's Economic Amnesia


Republican presidential hopeful Herman Cain appears to be suffering from a mild case of memory loss these days. In an article published last year at The Daily Caller, Cain writes, “The worst idea is a proposed national sales tax which is a disguised VAT (value added tax) on top of everything we already pay in federal taxes.”

The former CEO of Godfather’s Pizza is absolutely right. The trouble is his now famous “9-9-9 Plan” seems to cause quite a discrepancy with the above statement. To be fair, Cain was condemning the proposal of implementing a national sales tax without removing the massive tax burden already imposed on the American people. He goes on to suggest scrapping the entire tax code and replacing it with the Fair Tax. While I applaud his desire to abolish the 16th Amendment and the IRS, many of the criticisms given by Cain in the article could be directed at his current economic plan.

As he notes regarding the threat of a value added tax being imposed, Cain writes:

“In every country that has established a VAT with the promise of reducing its national debt, the VAT has eventually gone up or expanded on top of the existing tax structure. After discovering many of the tax grenades in the recently passed health care reform bill, which is already driving costs up and access down, it would be real easy for an overzealous bureaucrat to insert the language in the legislation ‘national retail and wholesale’ tax.”

Though Mr. Cain does not consider his tax plan to be a VAT, his points concerning the nature of government are just as applicable. Why should I trust an overzealous bureaucrat or politician under “9-9-9” any more than I do now? Why should job creators (the wealthy), feel more at ease with both an income and sales tax structure put in place?

To calm the nerves of his supporters, the Georgia native claims his plan is merely a stepping stone in the right direction of his desired goal to implement the Fair Tax. But yet again, Cain’s own words offer the greatest warning of what economic turmoil can develop from trusting such a promise:

“…Just look at the Social Security system, Medicare and Medicaid. Over the years since their inception, taxes have gone up, benefits have gone down… Giving the administration and Congress another tool to tax us and confuse us is like giving an alcoholic a key to the liquor store with no supervision, only to discover that he locks the door after he is safely inside.”

Once again, I find myself agreeing with the dire warnings of Herman Cain the writer, but am left with much dismay by Herman Cain the candidate. The previous quote illustrates a glaring inconsistency on Cain’s part as he seems to condemn the thought of trusting the government to not manipulate the tax code for its own ends and even casts the notion of expecting new taxes to not become destructive as naïve; unless of course he’s in office, in which case such dangers apparently cease to exist.

The most crucial point discussed in Cain’s article demonstrates the fundamental error in his 9-9-9 proposal. Despite the claims of economic growth and real wealth that will emerge should his tax plan be put in place, as Cain himself said last November, “…we have a spending problem in Washington, D.C., not a revenue problem.” Where are the substantive cuts in federal spending? How many departments is he abolishing? Should the American people be comforted by the thought that their wealth is being taken in a different manner? Is this what prosperity looks like?

Catchy slogans and “economic plans” are not going to bring about recovery. The tax plans proposed by Cain and many of the other candidates demonstrate the fatal flaw in mainstream economic thought: the notion that the economy can be planned. The issue is not necessarily how we are taxed, but why are we taxed and how much we are being taxed. It’s true a progressive income tax punishes success and drives jobs away overseas, but what is overlooked by such “revenue neutral” proposals as Cain supports is the amount of wealth being stolen from the productive sector of society and that government spending causes taxation in one form or another.

Prosperity only comes through production. Something must be produced before it can be consumed, and production is only possible through savings and investment. Real wealth and economic growth will only return to this country when we restore sound money and market interest rates that encourage savings, and drastically reduce the size and cost of government. This can only be achieved not by trusting the government to manage a new tax system, but by starving the beast. Don’t replace taxes, repeal them.

While such economic truths seem to have slipped the mind of business-savvy Herman Cain, they are truths the American people cannot afford to forget.


****

This piece originally appeared at RevoluTimes on November 8, 2011