Showing posts with label conservatism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conservatism. Show all posts

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Is War Conservative?


I originally wrote this for RevoluTimes on December 6, 2011
Of all the empty talking points presented as philosophical truisms, there is possibly no anecdote I find more obnoxious than the notion that being antiwar is necessarily a stance of the left. By antiwar I do not mean pacifism, but an opposition to the initiation of force and a general and healthy suspicion of the motives of the State and particularly when it engages in its most destructive and aggrandizing function: warfare.
When confronted with the Republican establishment narrative that Texas Congressman Ron Paul is a “leftist”, (I was recently told he’s actually to the left of Obama) because of his lack of zeal for preemptive war, I simply ask, “Were the Founders leftists as well?” Without missing a beat, the Fox News faithful will claim, “That was then, this is now. This isn’t the 18th Century.” It seems nothing gets passed these guys. Except for the fact that the non-interventionist foreign policy of the Founders was not due to some esoteric meme from a bygone era, but the product of historical and economic understanding gathered over the course of generations. Just as so-called conservatives rave daily about the abuses of State intervention domestically, the Framers understood all too well that governments do not miraculously become omniscient and flawless angels when it comes to intervening abroad. Were the leaders of the Republican Party as concerned with free markets and fiscal restraint as they claim, our ballooning overseas expenditures would not be an issue.
Arguably the two most famous of the Founding generation, George Washington and Thomas Jefferson were very clear in their warnings to avoid taking part in war unnecessarily.
George Washington would caution in his farewell address:
“…Observe good faith and justice towards all nations; cultivate peace and harmony with all…the nation which indulges towards another a habitual hatred or a habitual fondness is in some degree a slave. It is a slave to its animosity or to its affection, either of which is sufficient to lead it astray from its duty and its interest…So likewise, a passionate attachment of one nation for another produces a variety of evils. Sympathy for the favorite nation, facilitating the illusion of an imaginary common interest in cases where no real common interest exists, and infusing into one the enmities of the other, betrays the former into a participation in the quarrels and wars of the latter without adequate inducement or justification.”
Some years later, Jefferson would second Washington’s advice saying:
“…Equal and exact justice to all men, of whatever state or persuasion, religious or political; peace, commerce, and honest friendship with all nations, entangling alliances with none.”
Were Washington and Jefferson a couple of left-wing peaceniks? Or were they simply recognizing that nothing expands the size and scope of the State more than war? As Jefferson explained, a position of free trade among all nations creates the greatest incentive to avoid hostility. Prior to the spread of open trade and commerce, Europe experienced a long and gruesome history of conquest and wars, as the lack of trade resulted in each nation only able to consume what its own resources would provide; hence the desire for war. Through conquest and military force, not only could the resources of neighboring nations be consumed but conquering governments were presented with a new tax base to exploit as well. As the laissez-faire economist, Frederic Bastiat said, “When goods don’t cross borders, armies will.”
Bastiat and other proponents of laissez-faire avoided war, not out of some quaint idealism that other nations never posed a threat, but out of reverence for individual freedom and an appreciation for the power of the free market to transcend conflicts or disputes with foreign countries as both parties mutually benefit through peaceful, voluntary exchange. In fact, the policies of preventive war presented as a given today, are more akin to the philosophy of socialists and leftists than they are representative of the American right.
Writes Austrian economist Tom DiLorenzo,
“Like today’s neo-conservatives, nineteenth-century socialists branded classical liberals with the name ‘individualist,’ implying that classical liberals are opposed to fraternity, community, and association. But, as Bastiat astutely pointed out, he (like other classical liberals) was only opposed to forced associations, and was an advocate of genuine, voluntary communities and associations. ‘[E]very time we object to a thing being done by government, the socialists [mistakenly] conclude that we object to its being done at all.’”
Compare the socialist mindset of coerced community and pseudo philanthropy with the banner of “humanitarian war” the U.S. government parades under on its quest to defeat totalitarianism. To object to the notion that the U.S. military should be involved with every conflict around the world is heresy within the Beltway, and it’s further suggested that if government doesn’t act, (via war) then nothing will be done at all.
The conservative movement in America that began in the late 1940s and early 1950s was born out of this classical, (true) liberalism, based on property rights, capitalism, fiscal responsibility and an unwavering desire to limit government. Contrary to what is considered gospel among the GOP rank and file today, some of the staunchest opponents to empire and searching for monsters to destroy was the Old Right. In a speech at the Heritage Foundation in 1991, founder of the American conservative movement, Russell Kirk opined,
“Presidents Woodrow Wilson, Franklin Roosevelt, and Lyndon Johnson were enthusiasts for American domination of the world,” Kirk said in his speech. “Now George Bush appears to be emulating those eminent Democrats. When the Republicans, once upon a time, nominated for the presidency a ‘One World’ candidate, Wendell Willkie, they were sadly trounced. In general, Republicans throughout the twentieth century have been advocates of prudence and restraint in the conduct of foreign affairs…”
As Kirk illustrated, it’s no coincidence the so-called greatest presidents of the twentieth century we’re bombarded with in public schools, were all war presidents, and it’s also no coincidence those same presidents were responsible for some of the largest expansions of government at the time. Whether it was LBJ, George W. Bush or Barack Obama, Big Government and endless war go hand in hand. Prior to the shift of some Troskyites to the Republican Party in the 1960’s, a strong anti-imperialist fervor was a distinctive characteristic of the Old Right.
This common trait of prudence exhibited by the early conservative movement is perhaps articulated best by the most ardent defender of capitalism and freedom of the twentieth century, economist Murray Rothbard:
“It is in war that the State really comes into its own: swelling in power, in number, in pride, in absolute dominion over the economy and the society.”
If to be conservative is to value individual freedom, property rights, free trade and fiscal restraint, it must also be to guard against the influence of the State and to approach with caution every endeavor devised by it. If to be conservative is to oppose the billions in domestic spending that cause an unwarranted burden on the taxpayer, how does spending trillions overseas carry a lighter load? If to be conservative is to condemn the printing of money to rebuild roads here, should we not condemn printing money to bomb and rebuild roads abroad?  If we must forsake all of these principles for war, is war ever conservative to begin with?

The Tea Party's Identity Crisis


I originally published this article at RevoluTimes on December 1, 2011

The political circus being played by the GOP must leave one wondering if the Tea Party has all but abandoned its goals of fiscal restraint and smaller government. Rick Perry, Herman Cain and now Newt Gingrich have all been declared the frontrunner at some point throughout the presidential race despite their support for Big Government programs and government spending. Mitt Romney continues to poll well throughout the country but many conservative activists have refused to warm up to the former Massachusetts governor due to his many inconsistencies on the campaign trail.
This strong trend of searching for the Anti-Romney (similar sentiments were held during his presidential bid in 2008 as well) is rather puzzling considering the embrace given to the aforementioned candidates by much of the Republican Party and Tea Party supporters. The Tea Party and conservative activists across the country pride themselves on being defenders of capitalism, lower taxes and cuts to federal spending; but their propensity to latch onto whomever the Republican Party and conservative media is promoting at the moment makes this claim questionable at best.
The schizophrenia of right wing voters began with Rick Perry. As I’ve documented elsewhere, the Texas governor has a laundry list of tax hikes, corporate welfare and even a government mandate for young girls to purchase and be submitted to an HPV vaccine. As if this wasn’t enough to eradicate any rumors of Perry’s fiscal conservatism, Perry staunchly supported the springboard for the Tea Party movement: TARP. Indeed, not only did Perry support the bailout, he co-authored a letter with then president of the Democratic Governors Association, Joe Manchin saying,
“…There is a time for partisanship and there is a time for getting things done…and now is not the time to assign blame. It is time for D.C. to step up and be responsible and do what’s in the best interest of American taxpayers and our economy…It’s time for leadership. Congress needs to act now.”
Perry’s well-known history of pandering to special interests and unimpressive debate performances led many within the Tea Party to look towards Atlanta businessman Herman Cain. Cain’s candidacy had been an afterthought for several weeks due to his lack of name recognition; but his apparent outsider demeanor made him far more attractive as voters looked for an anti-establishment candidate. Yet again the so-called conservative media and grassroots organizers touted the latest frontrunner as a stalwart defender of free markets and fiscal responsibility. Little did most Republicans know, (and most still don’t know), Cain oncecondemned a national sales tax only to propose his own, vehemently opposes the notion of ending the Fed and restoring sound money and the coup de grĂ¢ce of course was Cain’s op-ed in strong support of TARP saying,
“…Wake up people! Owning a part of the major banks in America is not a bad thing. We could make a profit while solving a problem. But the mainstream media and thefree market purists want you to believe that this is the end of capitalism as we know it. It is not for several reasons that they have conveniently not explained…” (emphasis added)
It seems Mr. Cain believed the stealing of your wealth was just a wise investment the State was obliged to make for you. But despite his tarnished record and brand of political whimsy, the former CEO of Godfather’s Pizza held strong until allegations regarding his personal life were made public recently.
At this point the conservative masses were more than happy to offer the musical chair to former House Speaker Newt Gingrich. It’s not surprising to see the Georgia native rising in the polls as he’s very well known for his debate skills. It is baffling however that anyone with a straight face could claim Newt Gingrich believes in the free market or fiscal responsibility in any form. Not only did Gingrich support TARP, he staunchly supported the creation of the unconstitutional Department of Education, (and continues to push for its expansion) NAFTA and GATT, various federal subsidies, flip-flopped on Climate Change, received nearly $2 million from Freddie Mac and has repeatedly expressed his support for a federal mandate to purchase health insurance in some manner. And just to illustrate how little concern he has for actually cutting spending, Gingrich referred to the rather modest cuts presented earlier this year by Congressman Paul Ryan as “right wing social engineering”, only to once again change his mind later.
If the Tea Party and its supporters truly wish to be an agent of change and usher in a new age of free markets, sound money and fiscal restraint, they have a very strange way of showing it. As of right now, their choices in a presidential candidate will only result in them becoming a silenced wing of the Republican Party with little influence, and even less credibility. I’d suggest they return to their roots.

Liberty Rising: A Market Story


I originally published this article at RevoluTimes on November 25, 2011

Being the political junkie that I am, I often find myself debating one issue or another with friends, family and colleagues. This seems to be the trademark of the libertarian. When I’m not being completely denounced as “crazy” or “too radical” and am able to get a word in edgewise, I attempt to make the case for a truly free and voluntary society. The first and probably the most common objection to libertarianism I find is a lack of understanding or support for true capitalism. A frequent question I encounter from detractors is, “How do I hold any power under a free market?” To this I simply reply, “You are the free market.”
Capitalism and sound economics in general are often presumed to be exceedingly complex and confounding to the average person. There’s no doubt it requires vast knowledge and specialized skills to master, but ultimately economics is simply the study of human interaction and cooperation. What is often overlooked is that individuals act because of ideas and the degree to which those ideas shape society; the market is ruled by little else. Indeed, the groundswell of traditional conservatives, classical liberals and libertarians that is sweeping the nation today is nothing short of a market force. Just as all debit cards are rectangles because the market dictates this, (not because of some government regulation) and just as sold-out grocery stores during a blizzard are always re-stocked to fulfill consumer needs, societies respond and shape themselves in order to cater to new and innovative ideas.
Much like the founding of the Libertarian Party in 1971, the current surge in protests, political activism and independent media are acting as a market force to offer an alternative to the status quo. In the winter of 1971, as both major political parties were becoming increasingly authoritarian and the Old Right was vanishing, individualists and anti-statists of all stripes created what has become the nation’s third largest political party. This was all due to individuals taking it upon themselves to act on their ideas and fill a void in society that was needed.
The Libertarian Party continues to grow today, and in 2010 boasted 154 Libertarians holding public office. While their ranks have grown over the years, it has proven to be a long and mostly uphill road that has yielded poor results. Thanks to the advent of the internet, the philosophy of liberty has spread throughout the world and the plea for smaller government and more freedom was finally heard.
No one has taken advantage of the World Wide Web for the cause of liberty better than the Ludwig von Mises Institute. Their website Mises.org is a bastion of liberty and an intellectual powerhouse for the cause of free markets and individual freedom. Providing literally hundreds of books and thousands of articles and podcasts all for free, the site not only talks the talk but walks the walk.
The Mises Institute is yet another example of individuals taking action to provide a good or service, (in this case the scholarship of libertarian ideas) that was necessitated by the market. Founded by author Lew Rockwell with the blessing of Margit von Mises, (widow of classical liberal giant Ludwig von Mises) in 1982 and headed by libertarian hero and Austrian economist Murray Rothbard, (until his death in 1995) the institute’s purpose was to rekindle the old flame of laissez faire economics and to continue the teachings of the Austrian school. Having informed millions around the world with the scholarship of freedom and educated over 10,000 students in its summer Mises University program, the LvMI has proven to be indispensable in the struggle against the State.
In the last few years, organizations such as the Mises Institute and others have become very instrumental in education in the wake of government bailouts, unprecedented spending and endless wars. In 2008, a grassroots movement of the Tea Party shook the political establishment as it began to transcend the one dimensional narrative given by the Beltway talking heads. Inspired mostly by the presidential campaign of Texas Congressman Ron Paul, the Tea Party movement drastically impacted the 2010 elections and continues to be a strong force throughout the nation.
While I vehemently disagree with much of the conclusions presented by demonstrations such as Occupy Wall Street, it is indeed an important conversation to have. These protests, (that by now have likely been largely co-opted by the Democratic Party and professional activists) ironically began as just another example of the very market forces at work which so many leftists denounce. Similar to their right wing counterparts in the Tea Party, OWS was largely started by disenchanted left-liberals who no longer feel their representatives can be trusted and who recognize that the system is broken. Sadly, most are very misguided on how this occurred and what to do about it; but fortunately the market of ideas allows for competing philosophies– and we have history, economics and virtue on our side.
With the 2012 presidential elections heating up in a few short weeks, we may very well be nearing the pinnacle of this very long struggle for individual sovereignty as Congressman Ron Paul is rising in the polls despite concerted efforts to ignore him altogether. Despite the best efforts of the State and its cohorts to silence our ideas, the market has provided outlets for us such as Freedom Watch with Judge Andrew Napolitano, Adam vs. the Man with Adam Kokesh, Stossel, and of course this very website you are reading now, The RevoluTimes. As with all other products of the market that are developed by individuals, if we desire an abundant supply of freedom, we must never cease demanding it.

Newt Gingrich (D)


I originally wrote this piece for RevoluTimes on November 19, 2011

The growing sentiment across the country of “anyone but Obama” has placed the GOP, (driven by the enthusiasm of the Tea Party) front and center in American politics. The staggering number of Americans out of work and the unconscionable national debt has spawned a nationwide movement of voters searching for a candidate who will finally cut federal spending and shrink the size of government. Newt Gingrich is not that candidate.
Being a Georgia native, I’ve seen firsthand the masterful work of Gingrich the performer. It is unfortunately very rare to come across conservatives in Georgia who are aware of the former Speaker’s record. I’m sorry to say the two politicians Georgia is most noted for in modern times are Jimmy Carter and Newt Gingrich; contrary to popular opinion, the latter is no more conservative than the former. Despite his often touted, “Republican Revolution,” (which didn’t do much of anything at all) and harsh criticisms of Democrats’ endless spending, a look beyond the grandstanding and empty talking points reveals a charlatan, a professional blowhard who’s ability to rhetorically condemn big government policies is only overshadowed by his propensity to portray those same policies as conservative when they’re offered by Republicans.
One of the trademarks of George W. Bush’s big government conservatism, (and one of the scourges of the Tea Party) was the $400 billion Medicare Part D. Any self-respecting conservative has always wished to reduce the federal budget and the welfare state, not expand it. Gingrich on the other hand, strongly supported this increase in entitlement spending–and still does. Reports National Review:
“Gingrich supported Medicare Part D in 2003 — and the ensuing years haven’t made him any less supportive of the legislation. Asked in March if he regretted supporting the plan, Gingrich responded not with an apology, but with a ringing defense: ‘I feel strongly that the No. 1 purpose of health care is health, and Medicare was designed in the 1960s when pharmaceutical drugs were not a significant part of how you took care of people. And for us to have a government-run health plan that said we’re not going to help you with insulin but we’ll be glad to pay for kidney dialysis is an utterly anti-human provision. And so all I was in favor of was modernizing the system to recognize modern medicine.’”
While Newt’s words may indeed be comforting to seniors, they should be appalling to anyone who believes in constitutional government and particularly disturbing to those wishing to see a dramatic decrease in government spending and a restoration of the free market. Notice Gingrich does not seemed troubled at all by the notion of a “government-run health plan”; in fact he believes the government doesn’t go far enough. His statements regarding an opposition to government funded prescription drug benefits as being “anti-human” is predicated on the notion that without the State organizing and funding such care, it wouldn’t be available at all. How is this mentality and approach to government any different than that of liberal Democrats? For all of Newt’s lip-service to the free market, when the chips are on the table he folds every time.
Newt’s career is filled with endorsements of excessive and unconstitutional government spending and State interference in the marketplace. From ethanol subsidies, to No Child Left Behind and even a government bailout of the Mexican peso, one has to wonder how he’s managed to maintain his conservative cover for so long and why the Tea Party seems to favor him.
Perhaps it’s because the two policies most responsible for starting the Tea Party movement occurred while Newt was out of the limelight. His not being in Congress when TARP and ObamaCare were passed seems to have certainly helped to hide the fact that Gingrich supported TARP and has stated for years that he supports an individual mandate to purchase health insurance.
When asked in 2008 by George Stephanopoulos would he have voted for TARP, Gingrich replied:
“Sure, look, something has to be done. …I suspect were I still in Congress, in the end, George [Will] is right, and I would end up probably voting reluctantly yes…”
Newt’s right, something did need to be done, but not by the government. The market should have been allowed to liquidate the malinvestment, rather than such “troubled assets” being propped up at the expense of taxpayers. Newt’s tendency to presume so many social and economic ills can and must be remedied by government, rather than acknowledging government as the cause of much of our problems is further indicative of his insincerity when defending capitalism and the extent to which he’ll betray the economic freedoms and property rights of his supporters if given the opportunity.

One would think with such economic turmoil and anti-Obama sentiment pervading the country, supporting a government mandated purchase of health insurance would be a non-starter for anyone seeking public office. But the shape shifting Gingrich defies the odds as he has not only candidly admitted his support for an individual mandate over the years, but has also successfully condemned president Obama’s administration for imposing the same thing, simultaneously.
In an interview last May with NBC’s David Gregory on Meet the Press, Gregory played a video of Gingrich from a 1993 interview discussing health care in which Gingrich said,
“I am for people, individuals–exactly like automobile insurance–individuals having health insurance and being required to have health insurance. And I am prepared to vote for a voucher system which will give individuals, on a sliding scale, a government subsidy so we insure that everyone as individuals have health insurance.” (emphasis mine)
When asked by Gregory does he indeed advocate for an individual mandate, Gingrich replied,
“…I believe all of us–and this is going to be a big debate–I believe all of
us have a responsibility to help pay for health care…”
Continued Gingrich,
 “…And, and I think that there are ways
to do it that make most libertarians relatively happy. I’ve said consistently
we ought to have some requirement that you either have health insurance or you
post a bond…”
Not only does the former college professor have an obvious misunderstanding of libertarianism, but yet again Gingrich demonstrates his lack of conservative credentials. This notion of fixing big government rather than ending it has been seen throughout his career and persists in his current bid for the White House. His website remarks upon the need to “modernize the FDA”, (whatever that means) turn the Environmental Protection Agency into an “Environmental Solutions Agency that works collaboratively with local government and industry to achieve better results”, return to “Reagan era monetary policy”, (despite that Reagan appointed the destructive Alan Greenspan as Fed Chairman) and of course “Repeal and Replace” ObamaCare. Gingrich is the modern Republican Party personified. At no point is the prospect of actually reducing the size and scope of government and drastically cutting spending ever on the table. From the perspective of Gingrich and his fellow Rockefeller Republicans, excessive spending, crippling regulations and debasement of the currency aren’t to be condemned and certainly not to be reversed; but adjusted, revised and altered to the interests of the GOP.
The fundamental question that needs to be asked to Gingrich and each of the presidential candidates is this: Where are the actual CUTS in federal spending and where are you seriously shrinking the size of government? For far too long conservatives have confused pandering for principle, entertainment for integrity, and valued style over substance. If we are to truly turn the tide and rid our lives of government and restore prosperity, we can no longer afford to tolerate imposters, because political chameleons like Gingrich will always change their colors to mask what’s beneath the surface.