Showing posts with label foreign policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label foreign policy. Show all posts

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Is War Conservative?


I originally wrote this for RevoluTimes on December 6, 2011
Of all the empty talking points presented as philosophical truisms, there is possibly no anecdote I find more obnoxious than the notion that being antiwar is necessarily a stance of the left. By antiwar I do not mean pacifism, but an opposition to the initiation of force and a general and healthy suspicion of the motives of the State and particularly when it engages in its most destructive and aggrandizing function: warfare.
When confronted with the Republican establishment narrative that Texas Congressman Ron Paul is a “leftist”, (I was recently told he’s actually to the left of Obama) because of his lack of zeal for preemptive war, I simply ask, “Were the Founders leftists as well?” Without missing a beat, the Fox News faithful will claim, “That was then, this is now. This isn’t the 18th Century.” It seems nothing gets passed these guys. Except for the fact that the non-interventionist foreign policy of the Founders was not due to some esoteric meme from a bygone era, but the product of historical and economic understanding gathered over the course of generations. Just as so-called conservatives rave daily about the abuses of State intervention domestically, the Framers understood all too well that governments do not miraculously become omniscient and flawless angels when it comes to intervening abroad. Were the leaders of the Republican Party as concerned with free markets and fiscal restraint as they claim, our ballooning overseas expenditures would not be an issue.
Arguably the two most famous of the Founding generation, George Washington and Thomas Jefferson were very clear in their warnings to avoid taking part in war unnecessarily.
George Washington would caution in his farewell address:
“…Observe good faith and justice towards all nations; cultivate peace and harmony with all…the nation which indulges towards another a habitual hatred or a habitual fondness is in some degree a slave. It is a slave to its animosity or to its affection, either of which is sufficient to lead it astray from its duty and its interest…So likewise, a passionate attachment of one nation for another produces a variety of evils. Sympathy for the favorite nation, facilitating the illusion of an imaginary common interest in cases where no real common interest exists, and infusing into one the enmities of the other, betrays the former into a participation in the quarrels and wars of the latter without adequate inducement or justification.”
Some years later, Jefferson would second Washington’s advice saying:
“…Equal and exact justice to all men, of whatever state or persuasion, religious or political; peace, commerce, and honest friendship with all nations, entangling alliances with none.”
Were Washington and Jefferson a couple of left-wing peaceniks? Or were they simply recognizing that nothing expands the size and scope of the State more than war? As Jefferson explained, a position of free trade among all nations creates the greatest incentive to avoid hostility. Prior to the spread of open trade and commerce, Europe experienced a long and gruesome history of conquest and wars, as the lack of trade resulted in each nation only able to consume what its own resources would provide; hence the desire for war. Through conquest and military force, not only could the resources of neighboring nations be consumed but conquering governments were presented with a new tax base to exploit as well. As the laissez-faire economist, Frederic Bastiat said, “When goods don’t cross borders, armies will.”
Bastiat and other proponents of laissez-faire avoided war, not out of some quaint idealism that other nations never posed a threat, but out of reverence for individual freedom and an appreciation for the power of the free market to transcend conflicts or disputes with foreign countries as both parties mutually benefit through peaceful, voluntary exchange. In fact, the policies of preventive war presented as a given today, are more akin to the philosophy of socialists and leftists than they are representative of the American right.
Writes Austrian economist Tom DiLorenzo,
“Like today’s neo-conservatives, nineteenth-century socialists branded classical liberals with the name ‘individualist,’ implying that classical liberals are opposed to fraternity, community, and association. But, as Bastiat astutely pointed out, he (like other classical liberals) was only opposed to forced associations, and was an advocate of genuine, voluntary communities and associations. ‘[E]very time we object to a thing being done by government, the socialists [mistakenly] conclude that we object to its being done at all.’”
Compare the socialist mindset of coerced community and pseudo philanthropy with the banner of “humanitarian war” the U.S. government parades under on its quest to defeat totalitarianism. To object to the notion that the U.S. military should be involved with every conflict around the world is heresy within the Beltway, and it’s further suggested that if government doesn’t act, (via war) then nothing will be done at all.
The conservative movement in America that began in the late 1940s and early 1950s was born out of this classical, (true) liberalism, based on property rights, capitalism, fiscal responsibility and an unwavering desire to limit government. Contrary to what is considered gospel among the GOP rank and file today, some of the staunchest opponents to empire and searching for monsters to destroy was the Old Right. In a speech at the Heritage Foundation in 1991, founder of the American conservative movement, Russell Kirk opined,
“Presidents Woodrow Wilson, Franklin Roosevelt, and Lyndon Johnson were enthusiasts for American domination of the world,” Kirk said in his speech. “Now George Bush appears to be emulating those eminent Democrats. When the Republicans, once upon a time, nominated for the presidency a ‘One World’ candidate, Wendell Willkie, they were sadly trounced. In general, Republicans throughout the twentieth century have been advocates of prudence and restraint in the conduct of foreign affairs…”
As Kirk illustrated, it’s no coincidence the so-called greatest presidents of the twentieth century we’re bombarded with in public schools, were all war presidents, and it’s also no coincidence those same presidents were responsible for some of the largest expansions of government at the time. Whether it was LBJ, George W. Bush or Barack Obama, Big Government and endless war go hand in hand. Prior to the shift of some Troskyites to the Republican Party in the 1960’s, a strong anti-imperialist fervor was a distinctive characteristic of the Old Right.
This common trait of prudence exhibited by the early conservative movement is perhaps articulated best by the most ardent defender of capitalism and freedom of the twentieth century, economist Murray Rothbard:
“It is in war that the State really comes into its own: swelling in power, in number, in pride, in absolute dominion over the economy and the society.”
If to be conservative is to value individual freedom, property rights, free trade and fiscal restraint, it must also be to guard against the influence of the State and to approach with caution every endeavor devised by it. If to be conservative is to oppose the billions in domestic spending that cause an unwarranted burden on the taxpayer, how does spending trillions overseas carry a lighter load? If to be conservative is to condemn the printing of money to rebuild roads here, should we not condemn printing money to bomb and rebuild roads abroad?  If we must forsake all of these principles for war, is war ever conservative to begin with?

Foreign Policy Isn't Free


I originally published this piece at RevoluTimes on November 22, 2011

War is a racket… easily the most profitable, surely the most vicious… It is the only one in which the profits are reckoned in dollars and the losses in lives…. It is conducted for the benefit of the very few, at the expense of the very many. Out of war a few people make huge fortunes….I spent 33 years and four months in active military service and during that period I spent most of my time as a high class muscle man for Big Business, for Wall Street and the bankers.” -two time Congressional Medal of Honor winner, Major General Smedley Butler
When debating what should be cut from the federal budget, Washington promises that “everything’s on the table”. But is it? From entitlements to earmarks, congressional leaders and the president have spent the last several months pledging to address wasteful spending and restore fiscal sanity. Even if these sentiments were true, (which they’re not) it wouldn’t make any difference. No amount of tinkering around the edges or “reforms” of domestic spending is going to change the fact that our foreign entanglements around the world are not only destroying our liberties but crippling our economy. This cannot however be put completely at the feet of politicians as many Americans have yet to understand that there are limits to what the country can sustain.
The gut reaction to defend all military spending is understandable. If there is any legitimate role of government, it’s national defense. But in a post-9/11 world, the potential threat of terrorism has caused much of America to not question the reckless spending of the Pentagon. In our desperate attempt to feel secure, we’ve neglected our reason and placed faith in politicians. The same politicians and bureaucrats, who’ve proven to be unreliable and irresponsible with your tax dollars at home, haven’t suddenly become accountable and trustworthy when it comes to foreign policy.
Indeed few Americans are aware the Department of Defense is the only federal department expressly exempt from being audited. This alone should be startling to Americans, especially those concerned with an out-of-control government; but even more stunning is the fact that the US spends more on defense than all other nations combined. This is what economist and historian, Tom Woods has called, “The greatest fleecing of the American public in history.”
According to a recent study by the Eisenhower Research Project at Brown University, the U.S. has spent over $3.2-4 trillion on the wars in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan. The study noted these numbers do not include: “Medicare costs for injured veterans after age 65; Expenses for veterans paid for by state and local government budgets; Promised $5.3 billion reconstruction aid for Afghanistan; Additional macroeconomic consequences of war spending including infrastructure and jobs.”
David Callahan writing at The Policy Shop summarized the report saying,
“… the total direct and indirect costs of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan may exceed $6 trillion…. That figure comes from combining congressional appropriations for the wars over the past decade ($1.3 trillion), additional spending by the Pentagon related to the wars ($326 – $652 billion), interest so far on Pentagon war appropriations, all of which was borrowed ($185 billion), immediate medical costs for veterans ($32 billion), war related foreign aid ($74 billion), homeland security spending ($401 billion), projected medical costs for veterans through 2051 ($589 – $934 billion), social costs to military families ($295 – $400 billion), projected Pentagon war spending and foreign aid as troops wind down in the two war zones ($453 billion); and interest payments on all this spending through 2020 ($1 trillion).”
These estimates are also excluding military operations such as Libya, Yemen, Syria, Somalia andUganda.
While these numbers are unconscionable, a fact even more astounding is the number of U.S. military bases around the world. The problem is, there are so many, no one knows the exact number. Writes Antiwar.com’s Nick Turse:
“…there’s one number no American knows. Not the president. Not the Pentagon. Not the experts. No one… There are more than 1,000 U.S. military bases dotting the globe. To be specific, the most accurate count is 1,077. Unless it’s 1,088. Or, if you count differently, 1,169. Or even 1,180. Actually, the number might even be higher. Nobody knows for sure.”
Having over a thousand bases worldwide not only dwarfs any other nation’s foreign bases, but the magnitude of the bases themselves is overwhelming. As author Tom Engelhardt explains,
“India, a rising power, almost had one (but the Tajiks said no). China, which last year became the world’s second largest economy as well as the planet’s leading energy consumer, and is expanding abroad like mad (largely via trade and the power of the purse), still has none. The Russians have a few (in Central Asia where “the great game” is ongoing), as do those former colonial powers Great Britain and France, as do certain NATO countries in Afghanistan. Sooner or later, Japan may even have one… All of them together… add up to a relatively modest (if unknown) total. The U.S., on the other hand, has enough bases abroad to sink the world. You almost have the feeling that a single American mega-base like Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan could swallow them all up. It’s so large that a special Air Force “team” has to be assigned to it just to deal with the mail arriving every day, 360,000 pounds of it in November 2010 alone. At the same base, the U.S. has just spent $130 million building “a better gas station for aircraft … [a] new refueling system, which features a pair of 1.1-million gallon tanks and two miles of pipes.” Imagine that: two miles of pipes, thousands of miles from home – and that’s just to scratch the surface of Bagram’s enormity.”
It’s safe to say most Americans would be surprised, even shocked by these staggering numbers, but it is unfortunately also likely that many U.S. citizens would find such exorbitant costs necessary. We have been conditioned to trust government with such decisions and forgotten Randolph Bourne’s timeless warning, “War is the health of the State.”
There’s no denying domestic spending must be drastically cut as well, but while lawmakers in Washington have been playing political theatre, the U.S. has had its credit rating downgraded for the first time in history, we just recently reached a debt of $15 trillion and we’ve lost over 6,000 U.S. soldiers; at what point do we admit these are debts that cannot be paid?